Active Gear Review is supported by its audience. If you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Let me start by saying I like whiskey. But I also like weird food combinations and novelty drinks, so when I heard about peanut butter whiskey, my curiosity got the best of me. That brings me to today’s bottle: Screwball Peanut Butter Whiskey. You’ve probably seen this one at the liquor store. It’s hard to miss with the little sheep on the label and that slick, raised lettering that says “Screwball.” Their slogan? “To the misfits, black sheep, and screwballs.” Basically, anyone who likes to stir the pot…or in this case, stir the cocktail.
This bottle looks nice. They didn’t cheap out on the packaging, and for the price, usually between $25 and $35, I’m hoping they didn’t cheap out on what’s inside either.
If this isn’t already sitting in your liquor cabinet, you’ve probably at least seen it on the shelf. But whether you’ve tried it or you’re just peanut-butter-curious, let me walk you through it.
First Impressions
I cracked the bottle open, and before I even poured a drop, the smell hit me. It’s peanut brittle for sure. Sweet, nutty, and rich, like roasted peanuts covered in warm, melted sugar with a hint of whiskey in the background. Honestly, it smells better than I expected. Buttery, smooth, and definitely inviting.
The Taste Test
Alright, bottoms up.
The first sip…wow. It’s sweet. Really sweet. And I say that as someone who enjoys dessert cocktails now and then. But make no mistake, this isn’t your grandpa’s smoky bourbon. This is liquid caramel corn with a serious peanut butter kick. It goes down extremely smooth, no burn at all, which I can already tell will make it dangerous at parties.
The peanut flavor is front and center, but it’s backed up by this sugary, almost buttery finish. It reminds me of those Cracker Jack snacks that I ate as a kid.
The Cocktails
Screwball Peanut Butter Whiskey shines not just neat or in old classics, but especially in fun, refreshing cocktails. Here are a few I tried that highlight its unique flavor:
Tea Off Palmer
This one’s simple and bright. Combine:
- 2 oz Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey
- 1.5 oz lemonade
- 1.5 oz iced tea
Stir it all together and garnish with a fresh mint sprig. The whiskey’s nutty sweetness blends beautifully with the tart lemonade and smooth iced tea a perfect balance for a warm day.
PB&J Cocktail
Simple and sweet, this cocktail tastes like a grown-up peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Combine:
- 1.5 oz Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey
- 1 oz grape juice
- 0.5 oz lemon juice
- Splash of club soda (optional)
Shake with ice, strain into a glass over fresh ice, and top with club soda for a little fizz if you like. This drink is smooth, fruity, and refreshingly nostalgic.
Who Is This For?
If you love traditional whiskey, neat pours, barrel notes, high proof, this probably isn’t for you. If you love the burn and want to taste the oak, you’re going to roll your eyes at this one. But if you say you don’t like sweet drinks but secretly crush them when no one’s looking? This is your jam.
Screwball is perfect for:
- People who usually hate whiskey but love dessert
- Folks making novelty cocktails
- Anyone who thinks a PB&J shot sounds like a good time
- Reluctant party guests trying to survive the night
- People who consider Fireball a “serious whiskey”
Final Thoughts
Screwball Peanut Butter Whiskey isn’t for whiskey snobs, but it’s not pretending to be. It’s fun, sweet and dangerously easy to drink. And whether you sip it straight, take it as a shot, or toss it into a cocktail, it’s hard to deny its popularity.
Will I keep this on my shelf? Yeah, probably. Not for a serious whiskey night, but for parties or making quirky drinks? Absolutely.
For around $25 to $35 a bottle, it’s priced like a solid novelty liquor, not cheap, but not outrageous. You can find it pretty much everywhere now: major liquor stores, online retailers, and bars that serve Fireball shots with no shame. If you haven’t tried it, give it a shot. Even if you don’t love it neat, mix it up in a cocktail, it might surprise you. Peanut Butter Whiskey time? You bet. Cheers. For more info, visit skrewballwhiskey.com.