David Protein Bars – Tested: The Lineup Grows Stronger
Active Gear Review is supported by its audience. If you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
In a protein bar world littered with mediocrity, David Protein Bars have been quietly earning respect. They’re not perfect, but when they hit, they hit hard. The formula is simple: creative flavors, layered textures, and nutrition stats that make most competitors look underdosed and overpriced. With two brand-new flavors joining the roster, it’s time to step back and assess the full lineup.
Cinnamon Roll – A Warm Welcome (New)
Cinnamon Roll opens strong with that cozy, familiar scent of brown sugar and butter, the kind that reminds you of a mall food court but in a good way. The cinnamon is warm, not aggressive, and the creamy vanilla frosting notes help round it out. There’s a playful touch of salt in some bites, adding a savory undercurrent that keeps it from turning into a sugar bomb. Texturally, it’s on point: soft, pliable dough interspersed with white chocolate chunks and cookie crisps that give each bite some snap.
Rating: 8/10
Red Velvet – The Difficult One Done Right (New)
Red Velvet flavors often overpromise and underdeliver. Not here. David manages to thread that tricky needle with a blend of vanilla and chocolate cake batter that actually feels like red velvet. The butter and vanilla cream frosting notes bring just enough sweetness, and again, the touch of salt keeps it grounded. White chocolate chunks and crispy bits provide the familiar David texture that keeps every bite interesting.
Rating: 8/10
Blueberry Pie – The Reigning Champion
This one’s the star. It’s like biting into a blueberry pie…the taste is sweet and packed with real fruit flavor. The pie crust element comes through with vanilla cookie crisps and white chocolate chunks that add richness and texture. Every bite feels like it’s telling a story: sweet, creamy, crunchy, repeat. For a protein bar, this borders on decadent.
Rating: 9/10
Cake Batter – Underwhelming
Cake Batter wants to be fun but ends up mostly bland. The underbaked yellow cake flavor and vanilla buttercream frosting are present but muted. The usual texture mix of crisps and chunks saves it from total monotony, but this one feels like filler in the lineup.
Rating: 6/10
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough – A Disappointment
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough should be a slam dunk. Instead, it’s sticky with an artificial aftertaste that overshadows any promise of raw cookie dough flavor. The brown sugar, butter, and vanilla notes are drowned out, leaving the chocolate chunks and cookie crisps to carry what they can. Unfortunately, they can’t carry enough.
Rating: 5/10
Fudge Brownie – Reliable
It delivers what it says: dense, fudgey chocolate. Sweet and a little salty with rich chocolate chunks adding some bite. It’s a solid choice for chocolate lovers, but it doesn’t bring anything wildly new to the table. Safe, satisfying, but not exciting.
Rating: 7/10
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk – Solid, But Subtle
Peanut butter fans might wish for more punch here. The creamy peanut butter dough is pleasant, but muted. The roasted peanut crisps and chocolate chunks do good work texturally, but the peanut flavor never really takes center stage. Still, it’s an easy, inoffensive pick when you want a break from the sweeter flavors.
Rating: 7/10
Salted Peanut Butter – A Bit Uneven
Salted Peanut Butter starts with promise but stumbles on consistency. The peanut butter dough is smooth but barely delivers on peanut flavor. Some bites are super salty, others lack salt entirely. The creamy peanut chunks and roasted peanut crisps offer a nice crunch, but overall, it lands in the middle of the pack.
Rating: 6/10
The Final Word: A Growing Force in Protein Bars
David Protein Bars are doing something most brands fail at: making high-protein, low-calorie bars that you can actually look forward to eating. The flavor variety offers a bit of something for everyone, and while not every bar is a home run, there are clear standouts. Blueberry remains king. Cinnamon Roll and Red Velvet are strong new contenders that absolutely deserve your attention.
And let’s not forget the macros. With 8 grams more protein than many bars in its class, each of these easily earns a bonus point on sheer nutritional value alone. Grab a variety pack if you’re curious. But if you’re after guaranteed taste wins, start with Blueberry and Cinnamon Roll. For more info or to check them out for yourself visit davidprotein.com or amazon.com.
